Hero (Shutterstock).jpg


With our dozens of flavors of fudge, we have something for everyone! Explore our ever-expanding selection of fudge flavors below, and stop by our shop to taste a free sample of any that we currently have available!

  • Amaretto Chocolate Swirl: The swirl of red that runs through this chocolate fudge conceals a sweetness which lingers long after you've tasted it.

  • Awesome Chocolate: The can't-miss classic! Delicious chocolate fudge decorated with a sprinkling of chocolate shavings.

  • Birthday Cake: This intense vanilla fudge is decorated with a rainbow assortment of sprinkles; perfect for kids (and for kids-at-heart!)

  • Blueberry Cheesecake: The distinctive blue-and-white swirl of this flavor makes it one of our most eye-catching flavors, and it tastes as good as it looks.

  • Candy Cane: A holiday favorite! This vanilla-mint fudge can come in either a green or red swirl and is decorated with a layer of crushed peppermint.

  • Cappuccino: The white-and-brown swirl of cappuccino fudge, made with real coffee, has just a hint of cinnamon on top to delight your tastebuds.

  • Caramel Chocolate Peanut: Two layers of creamy chocolate surround a layer of caramel and peanuts – compare to a Snickers bar!

  • Chewy Praline: A mixture of caramel and pecans is nestled between a layer of chocolate fudge and a layer of vanilla fudge, all topped with a drizzle of caramel.

Fudge By Order


We sell our fudge in-store in pieces that are approximately 1/4 lb. each (with an everyday buy-2-get-1-free promotion!). When you visit, you can choose from any flavors we have available that day. But what if you want a lot of fudge, such as to share at a special event, or want to pick a flavor that we don't often have in our display? No worries! We offer 12- and 24-piece (approx. 3 lb. and 6 lb.) portions of fudge by special order, at a discounted rate! Reach out to us to discuss flavors, pricing, and when you'd like to have it ready, and let us make your fudge dream come true.

Mint Chocolate Swirl fudge
  • Cinnamon Chocolate Espresso: An intense mixture of real coffee, chocolate fudge, and a cinnamon-fudge swirl on top.

  • Cookie Dough: Topped with a sprinkling of chocolate chips, this vanilla fudge has bits of cookie dough mixed throughout - enjoy the popular ice cream flavor in fudge form!

  • Dark Chocolate Caramel Toffee: Delicious dark chocolate fudge mixed with Heath Toffee pieces makes for a winning combination. Topped with a caramel drizzle and a sprinkling of additional toffee pieces.

  • Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel: Our most popular flavor from our selection of truffles, now ready to be enjoyed in fudge form!

  • Heath Toffee: The slight crunch of the toffee pieces on top perfectly complements the creaminess of the fudge itself, which has more toffee mixed throughout.

  • Maple Bacon: Bacon? Who would have thought bacon would go with fudge? ...but, like chocolate and peanut butter, these two different tastes go great together, and we even decorate the top of the fudge to look similar to wavy red bacon strips.

  • Maple Chocolate Swirl: A favorite for late winter! Delicious maple fudge swirled with our classic chocolate fudge.

  • Maple Nut: This delicious maple fudge has pecans mixed throughout, as well as a sprinkling of chopped pecan pieces decorating the top.

  • Mint Chocolate Swirl: The bright green of the mint is an instant giveaway as to what flavor awaits within. Makes for a perfect winter treat!

  • Orange Chocolate Swirl: Though in color it looks like it belongs at a Halloween party, this delicious combination is great throughout both summer and fall!

  • Orange Cream: A fantastic summer treat! The orange-and-vanilla of this fudge is reminiscent of the popular ice-pop flavor combination.

  • Peach: Containing actual peach pieces, this fudge has a bit of tartness to it that perfectly complements the sweetness of the fudge.

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate: A classic for good reason!  The creaminess of the fudge causes the flavors to melt perfectly together in your mouth.

  • Peanut Butter & Jelly: Peanut butter fudge with raspberry jelly mixed through the top portion of it perfectly recreates the taste of the sandwich filling which this fudge gets its name from!

Freezing Fudge

Did you know? Our fudge can be frozen for months without losing any of its flavor! If you want to save some for later, simply wrap it in Saran-brand wrap or aluminum foil, and then place the wrapped fudge in a plastic freezer bag and freeze it. To thaw the fudge, take it out of the freezer, but keep it in the bag until the fudge reaches room temperature - this can take up to 24 hours depending on how large the piece is. It is important to let it thaw in the bag, to prevent any moisture in the air from condensing on top of the fudge. Then, remove it from the bag, and enjoy!

Orange Chocolate Swirl.jpg

Making Fudge

In the back room of our shop, we have a steel kettle which we use to make two different kinds of fudge: Chocolate and Vanilla. Starting from just these two kinds, we make all the various flavors you see listed on this page! Chocolate fudge can be turned into dark chocolate fudge with the addition of dark chocolate liquor, but for many of the flavors listed on this page, the basis is actually the vanilla fudge. By adding different ingredients, we can turn vanilla fudge into orange, or raspberry, or peanut butter fudge, among many others! Once we have the flavor we want, the fudge gets poured into pans to make a 6 lb "slab" of the desired flavor. Complex flavors will often have multiple layers poured on top of one another, and sometimes "swirled" together to create the wide range of designs seen in our fudge display every day. Once the fudge has been poured and suitable decorations added to it, it takes a day to set up, turning from the easy-to-work-with fluid form it started out as into the delicious, creamy fudge that we all know and love.

  • Raspberry Chocolate Swirl: Raspberry and chocolate are always a winning combination, and the raspberries used in making this fudge make the flavor really pop!

  • Raspberry Lemonade: The perfect summer drink, now in fudge form! The swirl of flavors in this brightly-colored fudge remain distinct as you enjoy them... one moment tasting like lemon, the next like raspberry.

  • Red Velvet: Designed to look like the cake it takes its name and flavor from, the layers of red and white in this fudge are topped with a sprinkling of chocolate pieces.

  • Root Beer Float: A fun and unexpected fudge flavor. Yes - it really does taste like root beer!

  • Rocky Road: Pecans and marshmallows are mixed throughout this delicious chocolate fudge, making for a wonderful assortment of textures in every bite!

  • Sherbert: This colorful layered fudge brings together a mix of fruit flavors reminiscent of rainbow sherbert. A perfect summertime treat!

  • Strawberry Cheesecake: Enjoy the popular dessert, now in fudge form!

  • Triple Berry Blend: Raspberry, Blueberry, and Strawberry fudge come together to create a delightful combination.

  • "Turtle": Named after the popular chocolate treat, this chocolate fudge containers a layer of caramel and pecans mixed together and a sprinkling of chopped pecans on top.

We're always experimenting with new fudge flavors! Have an idea for one you'd like us to try next? We'd love to hear it!